You’re viewing a version of this story optimized for slow connections. To see the full story click here.

6 Stops for National Vanilla Cupcake Day

The Village + a Brooklyn Bonus

Story by Nooklyn November 10th, 2015

Tuesday, Nov. 10 - National Vanilla Cupcake day

You can never have too many excuses to eat a cupcake - and it’s even better to have an excuse to eat MULTIPLE cupcakes.

So, here are 6 places you can grab a tasty cake today.

Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-6.jpg

Butter Lane

True to its name, the Vanilla cupcake at Butter Lane (East Village) is intensely buttery. Fun fact: They teach cupcake making classes here!

Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-8.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-1.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-3.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-4.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-9.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-7.jpg
Butter Lane - Vanilla Cupcake-10.jpg

Little Cupcake bakeshop

Vanilla. True, pure, intense vanilla flavor that lingers long after you take a bite. The pastry chef of NoLita based Little Cupcake Bakeshop, Sal, told me they import the best vanilla from Madagascar. The flavor comes through. If a wallop of vanilla flavor is what you’re after, they deliver best out of everyone on this list.

Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-4.jpg
Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-2.jpg
Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-5.jpg
Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-7.jpg
Little Cupcake Bakeshop- Vanilla Cupcake-8.jpg


Tu-Lu’s cupcake is moist, flavorful, and not too sweet - this well balanced cake was my favorite of the day. This East Village spot serves up cute mini cupcakes, as well!

Tu-Lu's Gluten-Free Bakery  - Vanilla Cupcake-9.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-18.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-20.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-16.jpg

Molly's Cupcakes

Molly’s offers a fun “build-your-own” cupcake approach, and their case was stocked with wild cupcake concoctions. But we’re here on a mission - so it’s vanilla on vanilla. Colorful sprinkles for flair.

Buttery, moist cake that has the distinct taste of batter. Intense, sweet icing. It was a little too much. I think this would have been the absolute best cupcake if it had about half as much icing. Now you know what to order. ;D

molly's cupcakes fixed.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-4.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-5.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-6.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-7.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-8.jpg
Molly's Cupcakes - Vanilla Cupcake-9.jpg

Sweet Revenge

If you’d like a little buzz to go along with your cupcake, the West Villiage’s Sweet Revenge is your place. The “Pure” is a mexican vanilla cake with mexican vanilla frosting sprinkled with crystal sugar. The pairing is Italian Principato Pinot Noir. They go great together.

Smaller for Photo Stories-45.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-42.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-46.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-54.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-57.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-50.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-59.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-64.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-65.jpg


Brooklyn Bonus! Red Hook’s Baked has an excellently balanced vanilla cupcake. Good all around. The texture is reminiscent of spoungecake, which was quite the departure from the other crumbly cupcakes sampled for this list.

Smaller for Photo Stories-68.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-67.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-70.jpg
Smaller for Photo Stories-71.jpg

Run out and grab your cupcake!

Let us know who has your favorite vanilla cupcake on Instagram @nooklynapp
Smaller for Photo Stories-63.jpg
Footnote: By Nicholas Doyle
New York, NY, United States
Read More